Evaluating Efficiency of Sampling Schemes in Tropical Natural Forests: Review and Simulation Experience from Kenya

Main Article Content

Joseph Hitimana
James Legilisho Ole Kiyiapi
Balozi Kirongo Bekuta


Forest measurements, especially in natural forests are cumbersome and complex. 100% enumeration is costly and inefficient. This study sought to find out reliable, efficient and cost-effective sampling schemes for use in tropical rain forest (TRF), moist montane forest (MMF) and dry woodland forest (DWF) in Kenya. Forty-eight sampling schemes (each combining sampling intensity (5, 10, 20, 30%), plot size (25, 50, 100, 400 m2) and sampling technique (simple random sampling, systematic sampling along North-South and along East-West orientations) were generated for testing estimates of forest attributes such as regeneration through simulation using R-software. Sampling error and effort were used to measure efficiency of each sampling scheme in relation to actual values. Though forest sites differed in biophysical characteristics, cost of sampling increased with decreasing plot size regardless of the forest type and attribute. Accuracy of inventory increased with decreasing plot size. Plot sizes that captured inherent variability were 5mx5m for regeneration and trees ha-1 across forest types but varied between forest types for basal area. Different sampling schemes were ranked for relative efficiency through simulation techniques, using regeneration as an example. In many instances systematic sampling-based sampling schemes were most effective. Sub-sampling in one-hectare forest unit gave reliable results in TRF (e.g. SSV-5mx5m-30%) and DWF (e.g. SSV-10mx10m-30%) but not in MMF (5mx5m-100%). One-hectare-complete-inventory method was found inevitable for regeneration assessment in montane forest.

Forest measurement, optimum plot size, inventory protocol, regeneration assessment

Article Details

How to Cite
Hitimana, J., Ole Kiyiapi, J., & Bekuta, B. (2019). Evaluating Efficiency of Sampling Schemes in Tropical Natural Forests: Review and Simulation Experience from Kenya. Asian Journal of Research in Agriculture and Forestry, 4(1), 1-15. https://doi.org/10.9734/ajraf/2019/v4i130051
Original Research Article


Schreuder HT, Gregoire TG, Wood GB. Sampling methods for multiresource forest inventory. John Wiley & Sons, Inc., New York; 1993.

Freese F. Elementary forest sampling. Agriculture Handbook no. 232. Oregon: US Department of Agriculture, Forest Service; 1989.

Lackmann S. Good practice in designing a forest inventory. Lesson 8. Regional Workshop: Capacity Development for Sustainable National Greenhouse Gas Inventories – AFOLU sector (CD-REDD II) Programme, Quito, Ecuador; 2011.

Avery ‎TE, Burkhart HE. ‎ Forest Measurements, 5th Ed. Illinois: Waveland Press; 2015.

Alder D, Synnott TJ. Permanent sample plot techniques for mixed tropical forest. Tropical Forestry Papers, Commonwealth Forestry Institute, University of Oxford. 1992;25.

Gerwing JJ, Schnitzer SA, Burnham RJ, Bongers F, Chave J, DeWalt SJ, et al. Standard Protocol for Liana Censuses. Biotropica. 2006;38(2):256–261.

Synnott TJ. A manual of permanent plot procedures for tropical rainforests. Tropical Forestry Papers. Commonwealth Forestry Institute, University of Oxford. 1979;14.

Gebreselasse AG. Plant Communities, Species Diversity, Seedling Bank and Resprouting in Nandi Forests, Kenya. Unpublished PhD Thesis, University of Koblenz-Landau; 2011.

Lee HS, Davies SJ, LaFrankie JV, Tan S, Yamakura T, Itoh A, et al. Floristic and structural diversity of mixed dipterocarp forest in Lambir Hills National Park, Sarawak, Malaysia. Journal of Tropical Forest Science. 2002;14(3):379-400.

Nilson M, Folving S, Kennedy P, Puumalainan J, Chirici G, Corona P, et al. Combining remote sensing and field data for deriving unbiased estimates of forest parameter over large regions. In, Corana, P., Kohl, M., & Marchetti, M. (Eds). Advances in Forest Inventory for sustainable Forest Management and Biodiversity Conservation; 2003.

Asthana DK, Asthana M. Environment: problems and solutions. Ramnagar, New Dheli: S. Chand and Company Ltd; 1998.

Hitimana J, Kiyiapi J, Njunge J. Forest structure characteristics in disturbed and undisturbed sites of Mt Elgon moist lower montane forest, western Kenya. Forest Ecology and Management. 2004;194:269-291.

Hitimana J, Kiyiapi J, Kisioh H, Warinwa F, Lenaiyasa P, Mayienda R, et al. Participatory ecological assessment of Kirisia forest reserve, Samburu, Kenya. AWF Technical Paper Series, Nairobi: African Wildlife Foundation; 2009.

Ucar Z, Bettinger P, Merry K, Siry J, Bowker JM, Andakbuluta R. A comparison of two sampling approaches for assessing the urban forest canopy cover from aerial photography. Urban Forestry & Urban Greening. 2016;16:221–230.

Nowak DJ, Crane DE, Stevens JC, Hoehn RE, Walton JT, Bond J. A ground-based method of assessing urban forest structure and ecosystem services. Arboric. Urban For. 2008;34:347–358.

Mutiso FM, Cheboiwo J, Kiyiapi JL, Sang FK, Hitimana J. Comparative Study of Sampling Methods for Efficient Diagnosis of Health Status of Selected Natural Forest Ecosystems in Kenya. Journal of Natural Sciences Research. 2016;5(2).

Weiskittel AR, Hann DW, Kershaw Jr, JA, Vanclay J. Forest growth and yield modeling. Wiley-Blackwell, Oxford, UK; 2011.

Burkhart HE, Tome M. Modeling forest trees and stands. Springer Science, London; 2012.

Warinwa F, Mwaura F, Kiringe JW, Ndubi AO. Land Cover Dynamics in the Kirisia Forest Ecosystem, Samburu County, Kenya. Advances in Remote Sensing. 2016;5:168-182.

Ronoh DK. Anthropogenic disturbance indicators and population structure of Zanthoxylum gillettii (De Wild Waterman) and Prunus Africana (Hook. f.) Kalkman in South West Mau Forest, Kenya. Unpublished master’s thesis, University of Kabianga; 2016.

Ronoh DK, Sirmah PK, Hitimana J, Mullah CJA. Variation in Regeneration Density and Population Structure of Prunus africana Across Human Disturbance Gradient in South West Mau Forest, Kenya. International Journal of Natural Resource Ecology and Management. 2018;3(1):1-8.

Kiruki HM, van der Zanden EH, Gikuma-Njuru P, Verburg PH. The effect of charcoal production and other land uses on diversity, structure and regeneration of woodlands in a semi-arid area in Kenya. Forest Ecology and Management. 2017; 391:282-295.

Clausnitzer V, Churchfield S, Hutterer R. Habitat occurrence and feeding ecology of Crocidura montis and Lophuromys flavopunctatus on Mt. Elgon, Uganda. African Journal of Ecology. 2003;41(1):1–8.

Bulafu CE, Mucunguzi P, Kakudidi EK. Diversity and distribution of wild terrestrial orchids of Mt Elgon Forest National Park, eastern Uganda. African Journal of Ecology. 2007;45 (3):21–28.

Hitimana J, Kiyiapi J, Njunge J, Bargerei R. Disturbance indicators and population decline of logged species in Mt Elgon Forest, Kenya. African Journal of Ecology. 2010;48:699-708.

Hitimana J, Kiyiapi JL, Kibugi PW, Kisioh H, Mayienda R, Warinwa F, et al. Challenges of linking socio-economic significance and conservation value of forests In Drylands of Kenya: Case study of Kirisia Forest - Samburu pastoralists coexistence. In: Grillo, O. & Venora, G. (Eds). Biological Diversity and Sustainable Resource Use. Intech. Chapter 2011;11-34.

Kiringe JW, Mwaura F, Warinwa F. Characterization of Water Source Types and Uses in Kirisia Forest Watershed, Samburu County, Kenya. Environment and Natural Resources Research. 2016;6(3).

Reed MS, Cokie MRJ. Effects of grazing and cultivation on forest plant communities in Mount Elgon National Park, Uganda. African Journal of Ecology. 2000;38(2): 154–162.

Hamilton AC, Perrott RA. A study of altitudinal zonation in the Montane Forest Belt of Mt. Elgon, East Africa. Vegetatio. 1981;45:107-125.

Vanclay JK. Realizing opportunities in forest growth modelling. Canadian Journal of Forest Research. 2003;33:536 – 541.

Pretzsch H. Forest dynamics, growth and yield, from measurement to model. Springer-Verlag, Berlin; 2010.

Nacoulma BMI, Schumann K, Traore S, Bernhardt-Roermann M, Hahn K, Wittig R, et al. Impacts of land-use on West African Savanna vegetation: a comparison between protected and communal area in Burkina Faso. Biodiversity Conservation. 2011;20:3341-3362.

Bellefontaine R, Petit S, Pain-Orcet M, Deleporte P, Bertault J. Trees outside forests: Towards better awareness. FAO Conservation guide 35, Rome; 2002.

Fashing P, Forrestel A, Scully C, Cords M. Long-term tree population dynamics and their implications for the conservation of the Kakamega forest, Kenya. Biodiversity and Conservation. 2003;13:753–771.

Joetzoald R, Schmidt H. Farm Management Handbook of Kenya, West Kenya. II/A. 1983;309–324.

Kokwaro J. Conservation status of the Kakamega forest in Kenya: The easternmost relic of the equatorial rain forest of Africa. Monographs in Systematic Botany Missouri Botanocal Garden. 1988; 25:471–489.

Mutiso FM, Hitimana J, Kiyiapi JL, Sang FK, Eboh E. Recovery of Kakamega tropical rainforest from anthropogenic disturbances. Journal of Tropical Forest Science. 2013;25(4):566–576.

Feld CK, da Silva PM, Sousa JP, de Bello F, Bugter R, Grandin U, et al. Indicators of biodiversity and ecosystem services: A Synthesis across Ecosystems and Spatial Scales; 2009.

Hamilton AJ. Species diversity or biodiversity? Journal of Environmental Management. 2005;75:89–92.

Brower JE, Zar JH, Von Ende. Field and Laboratory Methods for General Ecology, 4th Ed. Boston, Mass: WCB McGraw-Hill; 1998.

Hitimana J. Structure, Composition and Regeneration of Mt Elgon Moist Lower Montane Forest (Kenya) with Particular Interest in Olea capensis subsp. welwitschii. M.Phil. Thesis, Moi University; 2000.

Beentje HJ. Kenya Trees, Shrubs and Lianas. Nairobi: National Museums of Kenya; 1994.

Muchiri MN, Ngugi J, Kinyanjui M, Balozi K, Ojuang F, Nduati P, et al. Improving Capacity in Forest Resources Assessment in Kenya (IC-FRA): Field Manual for Biophysical Forest Resources Assessment in Kenya. KEFRI, Muguga; 2016.

Klauberg C, Vidal E, Silva CA, de M, Bentes M, Hudak AT. Sampling methods for titica vine (Heteropsis spp.) inventory in a tropical forest. Annals of Forest Science. 2016;73:757–764.

Morais R, Sheuber M. Statistical precision in phytosociological surveys. In: Proceedings of the International Symposium on Assessment and Monitoring of Forests in Tropical Dry Regions with special reference to Gallery Forests. Brasilia. 1996-1997;135-147.

Wong JLG, Thornber K, Baker N. Resource assessment of non-wood forest products: experience and biometric principles. FAO, Rome; 2001.

Cavalcanti FJB, Machado AS, Osokawa RT, Cunha US. Comparison of the estimated values by sampling in the characterization of the structure of a forest area in the Amazon with the information recorded in forest census. Revista Árvore. 2011;35:1061–1068.